Welcome to Tionesta Seldom Inn
Tionesta Seldom Inn, located at 701 PA-36 in Tionesta, PA, has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. This inviting establishment boasts a warm atmosphere, highlighted by friendly service from talented staff, including the amusing bartender Carrie. Renowned for its exceptional pizza, patrons rave about signature dishes like the Buffalo chicken and white pizzas, along with a variety of satisfying bar foods such as fried fish and homemade tacos. With new ownership focused on elevating quality and hospitality, Tionesta Seldom Inn invites you to enjoy a dining experience that exceeds expectations in both flavor and friendliness.
-
701 PA-36, Tionesta, PA 16353, United States Hotline: +1 814-560-3131
Welcome to Tionesta Seldom Inn, a gem nestled in the heart of Tionesta, Pennsylvania, at 701 PA-36. With a phone number of +1 814-560-3131, this establishment is rapidly gaining a reputation as a local favorite. What sets Tionesta Seldom Inn apart is its delightful combination of warm hospitality and an impressive menu brimming with flavor. Patrons are greeted by a friendly atmosphere, courtesy of a staff led by owner Tony, whose commitment to creating an inviting space is evident in every interaction.
The reviews speak volumes about the quality of food offered here. Lori Serio highlights the lively and welcoming nature of the place, especially praising bartender Carrie for her hilarious charm. Meanwhile, Robin Taylor's experience underscores the allure of the inn's famous pizza—initially a curious glance turned into an unforgettable taste sensation. The consensus is clear: the pizza here is not just good; it’s fabulous. Greg Putney raves about it, proving that sometimes, simplicity can yield greatness.
But pizza isn't all that’s on the menu. Carmen A expresses delight at the transformation under new ownership, particularly pointing out dishes like the fried fish and hot sausage. They even compare the quality of food to that found in downtown Pittsburgh—no small feat! Julie Curry echoes this sentiment, relishing fresh ingredients in both tacos and pizza, clearly indicating that Tionesta Seldom Inn is not merely a bar but a culinary destination.
For those seeking that perfect pizza experience, Brian Byrge suggests trying the Buffalo chicken pizza, while Victoria Soulshine had her expectations exceeded with the standout service and the “best pizza” she’s had in ages. Doug Hinchberger shares a similar story, noting the chef's friendly recommendations and the delightful surprise of the white pizza. Such personal touches showcase the commitment of the staff to ensure every visitor feels valued and satisfied.
With every anecdote, it’s evident that Tionesta Seldom Inn has sparked a sense of community, woven through laughter, great food, and friendly faces. Whether you're just passing through or settling in for dinner, this establishment promises an experience filled with warmth and flavor that you won't forget. So, if you're in the area, make this your go-to spot—your taste buds will thank you!
Bartender (Carrie) is very friendly, as well as hilarious! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming.
Have stopped several times for a drink but decided to give the pizza a try today since each time we see it, looks delicious! It tastes even better. The bartenders and owners are so nice along with all the friendly patrons. Definitely our new favorite place
Absolutely love this place. Just pizza. NOT, this pizza is fabulous.
Admittedly I wasn't sure what to expect with the new ownership, but we were very pleasantly surprised. The food is exceptional for "bar food"; the fried fish, hot sausage, and French fries are my current favorites. The owner and staff are very hospitable and welcoming. The food rivals (similar) restaurants in downtown Pittsburgh. No joke. Food went from a 2 to a 10. We will back for sure!
We have a camp nearby but never been here before, for whatever reason. After reading the reviews we decided to stop in for lunch and we’re glad we did. We shared tacos and a pizza. Both were made with fresh quality ingredients but the pizza was awesome. We really enjoyed it. The bartender was attentive and friendly and the place was very clean and nice inside. We will definitely be back for pizza but we also want to try other menu items. Check it out, you won’t be disappointed.
New Ownership is fantastic and staff is all friendly. Food is very good as well. The pizza is a highlight on the menu, with the Buffalo chicken pizza being a personal favorite.
This place was fantastic. The place was clean. The waitress was friendly and I could tell she enjoyed her job. The pizza was the best I've had in a long time. The pizza maker was such a nice fella. The owner I assume was out at tables and talking about his food and menu. It was great. We have a camp near by and this will be our go to. 1 thing, we enjoy sweet sweet tea.. Everything else by far exceeded expectations 10 fold.
Stopped for some drinks and pizza today. Pizza was absolutely amazing. The owner Tony told us how good the white pizza was and we told hims we'd have to stop by and try it. Next thing we knew he was bringing us one out. He was right. It was amazing too. The bartender was awesome also. Place has come a long way. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area. You can tell Tony is very interested in making it a great place. And he is succeeding in doing that!